Finding the right golf club characteristics for a player is often as much a matter of the right Feel of the club as it is getting specific values of flex and MOI/swingweight for the player. The "numbers" may sometimes not be as important as putting a club in a player's hands that simply FEELS right.
In a driver fitting this weekend, we determined that the player needed a shaft that was quite a bit softer in flex than what he was playing. Also shorter in length than he was playing. And pretty high loft, about 15 degrees.
But then it got interesting. With the club that was the best first-level flex and length, we started adding weight to the clubhead to see how if affected how the club felt and how he could release the clubhead at impact. We got to a certain added head weight and he said "that feels really good."
We added 2 grams more weight - he could not close the clubhead as easily. I was looking to make some other changes to the feel of the clubhead, but he absolutely did NOT want anything but the one that "really feels good."
No doubt in my mind after that feedback that that club was the right one to build. Built it tonight to exactly the specs of the test club and hopefully the snow will stop enough soon so that he can get to hit it.
I am always a bit amazed at how players can hit on a club that is Absolutely the best feel for them, and how this is certainly the club that is the best fit. To me player feedback is at the same level of importance as that from launch monitors, impact labels, and precision test clubs.
Tony
Showing posts with label golf club feel. Show all posts
Showing posts with label golf club feel. Show all posts
Monday, December 13, 2010
Monday, February 15, 2010
When Is Light Right?
One of the big rages at the PGA show this year was lighter clubs and grips. A couple of the major companies are marketing grips a lot lighter than standard, and you probably are also seeing some companies saying they now have the lightest driver available - and suggesting you will get great improvements in distance with those clubs.
Is lighter ever really better? I would say that if someone suggests that making a club lighter AND longer is going to really help that you should be wary. However, there can in fact be conditions where lighter is worth looking at.
I built a slightly different driver for myself this past week that seems to help me reduce some of my major "misses." My usual poor miss with the driver is to the right. Most times when I do this I have been able to "feel" that I have not closed the clubhead. I have always thought this was largely a swing fault...............and most likely there is some element of that. But the driver I just built for myself is an SMT Nemesis....................a smaller head (around 400 cc) and easier to "close" than typical 460 cc heads. And I also built this club about 40 MOI points less than my previous driver - roughly 4 grams less head weight than I had been using.
Results? This past Sunday I drove the ball MUCH better than I had been. A few misses to the right but a lot more draws and straight shots. And also a greater feel for the clubhead and feel for the ability to close it when I hit the ball. Now if it would ONLY stop being so cold when I play.....(37 degrees.....).
So maybe it is possible that a lot of your typical misses are not fully the result of your swing...........or at the very least you can find a combination of clubhead size and club MOI/swingweight that can make your driver FEEL easier to swing.
Tony
Is lighter ever really better? I would say that if someone suggests that making a club lighter AND longer is going to really help that you should be wary. However, there can in fact be conditions where lighter is worth looking at.
I built a slightly different driver for myself this past week that seems to help me reduce some of my major "misses." My usual poor miss with the driver is to the right. Most times when I do this I have been able to "feel" that I have not closed the clubhead. I have always thought this was largely a swing fault...............and most likely there is some element of that. But the driver I just built for myself is an SMT Nemesis....................a smaller head (around 400 cc) and easier to "close" than typical 460 cc heads. And I also built this club about 40 MOI points less than my previous driver - roughly 4 grams less head weight than I had been using.
Results? This past Sunday I drove the ball MUCH better than I had been. A few misses to the right but a lot more draws and straight shots. And also a greater feel for the clubhead and feel for the ability to close it when I hit the ball. Now if it would ONLY stop being so cold when I play.....(37 degrees.....).
So maybe it is possible that a lot of your typical misses are not fully the result of your swing...........or at the very least you can find a combination of clubhead size and club MOI/swingweight that can make your driver FEEL easier to swing.
Tony
Monday, September 7, 2009
FEEL FEEL FEEL ..... A great 4 letter word!
Not every player I build clubs for is greatly sensitive to Club Feel. But almost all are to some extent. I am now midway into a fitting with a good player who is very sensitive to the desire to feel the clubhead. And about to start a fitting for a player who I know needs clubs that are a lot longer than normal......and for him Feel may be more important that for "standard" length players.
Feel is the Bottom Line of a golf club. I believe that if a club does not feel good in your hands you will never truly hit it well. When I do fittings I am constantly asking how one club feels vs another test club and I weigh highly what players tell me about feel.
What affects club feel? Just about everything! For sure the club MOI or swingweight are a measure of feel - and these are influenced by head weight, shaft weight, club length, and club flex.
I do not think it is easy to quantify what makes one club "feel" better than another - but that does not mean that finding the right feel for a player is not perhaps the most important thing that a professional clubfitter can do.
Tony
Feel is the Bottom Line of a golf club. I believe that if a club does not feel good in your hands you will never truly hit it well. When I do fittings I am constantly asking how one club feels vs another test club and I weigh highly what players tell me about feel.
What affects club feel? Just about everything! For sure the club MOI or swingweight are a measure of feel - and these are influenced by head weight, shaft weight, club length, and club flex.
I do not think it is easy to quantify what makes one club "feel" better than another - but that does not mean that finding the right feel for a player is not perhaps the most important thing that a professional clubfitter can do.
Tony
Monday, June 1, 2009
"Rules Are Nice, But Fitting Rules"
In an AGCP post today, Russ Ryden said the quote that I used as the title for this blog post. I think it is a terrific statement of what AGCP and other professional clubfitters do - and particularly what differentiates us from folks who do clubfitting in typical golf club sales stores.
Russ, by the way, has a terrific web site for his fitting business - www.fit2score.com.
There are a lot of technical elements to professional clubfitting - analyzing launch monitor data and building test clubs to specific flexes and lengths are some examples. And I believe we all want to find elements of clubfitting that we can reduce to a formula - like for example what specific iron flex would correspond to the best fit for a specific client swing speed. And there are parts of fitting that can be reduced to following some rules.
But I think there is also some art - based on experience - in doing great fitting. Using the basics to produce some initial ideas of what the right fit might be, but also then using what you have learned from past experiences to really produce a solution that is right for a golfer. Learning to listen to customers tell you what "feels" best and factoring that into fitting recommendations is another example.
This past weekend I did a driver fitting where the ultimate value was in moving past the basics into using past experience to find a good solution. The player is someone who has the capability to drive the ball well, but also pretty consistently pull hooks the ball. We did the basic things of identifying the right length club - 44-1/2 inches rather than his present 45 inches - and the right shaft flex profile for his swing. But if we had ended then he would still pull most likely pull-hook the ball on lots of his drives.
We made an approximate measurement of the swingweight of his present driver - D0. Many stock drivers you can buy in stores have this swingweight, and for some "average" golfer that might be a good club swingweight. But this club was too light for this golfer, and as a result he had to keep adjusting his swing to guard against pull hooking and often was not successful.
We added weight to his club - using lead tape - 2 grams at a time until we had added about 10 grams to the club - about a D5 swingweight now; he hit shots with each addition of weight. When we added this weight he hit some very good drives that started slightly right and then drew back to the middle. Beautiful. Before he left to play golf in the afternoon, I put 10 grams of lead tape onto the bottom of his present driver and asked him to tell me what the results were.
Today I talked with him, and his driving results were mixed but I think positive because of one thing that he said to me. He said when he remembered that I said to him to "relax and let the club hit the ball" that he hit his best drives. He knows that some lessons will help him hit the ball better, but he also knows that when I have rebuilt his driver to a D5 swingweight with a shaft chosen for his swing, he will be a playing a driver that works for the way HE hits the ball.
Fitting really does rule!
Tony
Russ, by the way, has a terrific web site for his fitting business - www.fit2score.com.
There are a lot of technical elements to professional clubfitting - analyzing launch monitor data and building test clubs to specific flexes and lengths are some examples. And I believe we all want to find elements of clubfitting that we can reduce to a formula - like for example what specific iron flex would correspond to the best fit for a specific client swing speed. And there are parts of fitting that can be reduced to following some rules.
But I think there is also some art - based on experience - in doing great fitting. Using the basics to produce some initial ideas of what the right fit might be, but also then using what you have learned from past experiences to really produce a solution that is right for a golfer. Learning to listen to customers tell you what "feels" best and factoring that into fitting recommendations is another example.
This past weekend I did a driver fitting where the ultimate value was in moving past the basics into using past experience to find a good solution. The player is someone who has the capability to drive the ball well, but also pretty consistently pull hooks the ball. We did the basic things of identifying the right length club - 44-1/2 inches rather than his present 45 inches - and the right shaft flex profile for his swing. But if we had ended then he would still pull most likely pull-hook the ball on lots of his drives.
We made an approximate measurement of the swingweight of his present driver - D0. Many stock drivers you can buy in stores have this swingweight, and for some "average" golfer that might be a good club swingweight. But this club was too light for this golfer, and as a result he had to keep adjusting his swing to guard against pull hooking and often was not successful.
We added weight to his club - using lead tape - 2 grams at a time until we had added about 10 grams to the club - about a D5 swingweight now; he hit shots with each addition of weight. When we added this weight he hit some very good drives that started slightly right and then drew back to the middle. Beautiful. Before he left to play golf in the afternoon, I put 10 grams of lead tape onto the bottom of his present driver and asked him to tell me what the results were.
Today I talked with him, and his driving results were mixed but I think positive because of one thing that he said to me. He said when he remembered that I said to him to "relax and let the club hit the ball" that he hit his best drives. He knows that some lessons will help him hit the ball better, but he also knows that when I have rebuilt his driver to a D5 swingweight with a shaft chosen for his swing, he will be a playing a driver that works for the way HE hits the ball.
Fitting really does rule!
Tony
Monday, March 16, 2009
Opti Vibe Power Weights - The FEEL Word!!
I think there is an amazing trend in clubfitting in the area of Counterweighting. The concept of Counterweighting has been around a long time.....some of you probably know that Jack Nicklaus did this with his clubs - he put weight into the butt end of his clubs.
A company named Tour Lock Pro initially developed some counterweights to simply install in the butt end of golf clubs. They and their customers over the past few years have had a lot of success improving things like driver swing speed - in many cases increasing swing speed measureably, sometimes around 4 mph - and improving the performance of irons with counterweights.
They also have had great success with Putter Fitting - by putting more weight into the butt end of clubs players can often improve the Feel of their putting stroke. And particularly for folks who have some hand tremors, counterweighting of clubs can lead to great improvement in putting. I was told a year or so ago that most fitters have had about 85% success in improving putter feel using counterweights.
Now they have carried this a next step with what they call Opti Vibe Power Weights. In addition to putting some weight into the butt end of clubs (usually about 12 grams) they have developed weights that they can put DOWN the shaft to change the balance point and again FEEL of the golf club. I believe that they have usually used 15 or 25 gram weights down the shaft and again have had some great results with this to improve driver swing speed.
However, I think if you follow the golf world you are going to hear pretty soon about some great successes with professional golfers and the Opti Vibe Power Weights particularly for Putting. For improving putter feel, they typically put 50 to 100 gram weights down the shaft - between 4 inches and 12 inches down the shaft depending on what is the best feel. I cannot name names, but there are now a number of players on the Senior Tour using these weights in their putters and they love them.
I have not done much with the putting weights yet, but I am going to start experimenting with them soon. I bought the 50 and 100 gram weights, and in a week or so am going to "test" these with Des Mahoney at Centenial, and see if he experiences significant improvement in putter feel with them. I expect to find good results from these tests, and assuming so am going to start offering the opportunity for local players to test the Opti Vibe weights in their putters and see the results.
If you are interested in participating in some testing of these weights, email me at tony@gameimprovementgolf.com and I can arrange a time to do some testing with you.
In the meantime, if you are interested in more information here is a web site that you can go to for that:
www.golfclubcounterweighting.com
Tony
A company named Tour Lock Pro initially developed some counterweights to simply install in the butt end of golf clubs. They and their customers over the past few years have had a lot of success improving things like driver swing speed - in many cases increasing swing speed measureably, sometimes around 4 mph - and improving the performance of irons with counterweights.
They also have had great success with Putter Fitting - by putting more weight into the butt end of clubs players can often improve the Feel of their putting stroke. And particularly for folks who have some hand tremors, counterweighting of clubs can lead to great improvement in putting. I was told a year or so ago that most fitters have had about 85% success in improving putter feel using counterweights.
Now they have carried this a next step with what they call Opti Vibe Power Weights. In addition to putting some weight into the butt end of clubs (usually about 12 grams) they have developed weights that they can put DOWN the shaft to change the balance point and again FEEL of the golf club. I believe that they have usually used 15 or 25 gram weights down the shaft and again have had some great results with this to improve driver swing speed.
However, I think if you follow the golf world you are going to hear pretty soon about some great successes with professional golfers and the Opti Vibe Power Weights particularly for Putting. For improving putter feel, they typically put 50 to 100 gram weights down the shaft - between 4 inches and 12 inches down the shaft depending on what is the best feel. I cannot name names, but there are now a number of players on the Senior Tour using these weights in their putters and they love them.
I have not done much with the putting weights yet, but I am going to start experimenting with them soon. I bought the 50 and 100 gram weights, and in a week or so am going to "test" these with Des Mahoney at Centenial, and see if he experiences significant improvement in putter feel with them. I expect to find good results from these tests, and assuming so am going to start offering the opportunity for local players to test the Opti Vibe weights in their putters and see the results.
If you are interested in participating in some testing of these weights, email me at tony@gameimprovementgolf.com and I can arrange a time to do some testing with you.
In the meantime, if you are interested in more information here is a web site that you can go to for that:
www.golfclubcounterweighting.com
Tony
Monday, March 2, 2009
Club Balancing - "Swingweight" and "MOI" Matching
I recently took a big step in moving toward being able to make better "matched" golf clubs for my golf club clients. I purchased a device called the "MOI Speed Match" system from Tom Wishon golf. Tom Wishon has long been a proponent of using MOI matching instead of Swingweight matching of golf clubs - particularly for irons.
MOI matching and Swingweight matching of a set of irons are based on the same premise - having the full set of irons feel the same when you swing them.
Swingweight and MOI are based on somewhat different principles....
SWINGWEIGHT - I believe the concept of swingweight has been best defined by Ralph Maltby of Golfworks - "the measurement of a golf club's weight about a fulcrum point which is established at a specified distance from the grip end of the club." Swingweight is all about the weight distribution between the head of the golf club and the grip end of the golf club. Increasing the head weight and increasing shaft weight make swingweight increase, increasing the weight of the golf grip makes swingweight decrease. A relative weight scale was developed to denote different swingweights - so a D1 swingweight is larger than a C6 swingweight.
MOI - this is an actual physical measurement that is made for a golf club, it has dimensional units of mass/(length*length). It is a measure of how easy or difficult it is to swing a golf club. Interestingly, the weight of the grip has little if any influence on the measured MOI of a golf club.
How do swingweight matched clubs differ from MOI matched clubs? If you have a set of MOI matched clubs, you will find that the swingweights of the higher irons are lower than the swingweights of the shorter irons. Some fitters actually attempt to approximately MOI match a set of clubs by "progressive swingweighting" - increasing the club swingweight by typically 1/2 swingweight point between clubs - for example, the 6 iron swingweight would be 1/2 point higher than the 5 iron swingweight.
Proponents of iron swingweight matching believe that you should determine the best iron swingweight - which produces the best performance - and keep that constant for your main irons - for example 5 iron through 9 iron. Most swingweight proponents I believe feel that the wedges should have a bit higher swingweights than the other irons.
Proponents of MOI matching believe that you identify the best iron MOI for the player and then build the full set of irons to that MOI. They also believe that if you have a set of MOI matched clubs, that you can ask a player to swing their 5 iron and 9 iron with their eyes closed and they will not be able to tell you which one they are swinging.
So why am I making a commitment to moving to applying MOI matching in all of my iron fittings? It is largely from feedback from some of the most influential clubfitters in the country and the world. I am aware of one fitter who has done more than 1,500 MOI iron fittings with excellent results, and of another who has done hundreds of fittings and had only 1 poor result. I also recently learned that MOI matched clubs are starting to make their way on the professional golf tours.
Having golf clubs that feel the same when you swing them to me is an edge that golfers should have available to them.
Tony
MOI matching and Swingweight matching of a set of irons are based on the same premise - having the full set of irons feel the same when you swing them.
Swingweight and MOI are based on somewhat different principles....
SWINGWEIGHT - I believe the concept of swingweight has been best defined by Ralph Maltby of Golfworks - "the measurement of a golf club's weight about a fulcrum point which is established at a specified distance from the grip end of the club." Swingweight is all about the weight distribution between the head of the golf club and the grip end of the golf club. Increasing the head weight and increasing shaft weight make swingweight increase, increasing the weight of the golf grip makes swingweight decrease. A relative weight scale was developed to denote different swingweights - so a D1 swingweight is larger than a C6 swingweight.
MOI - this is an actual physical measurement that is made for a golf club, it has dimensional units of mass/(length*length). It is a measure of how easy or difficult it is to swing a golf club. Interestingly, the weight of the grip has little if any influence on the measured MOI of a golf club.
How do swingweight matched clubs differ from MOI matched clubs? If you have a set of MOI matched clubs, you will find that the swingweights of the higher irons are lower than the swingweights of the shorter irons. Some fitters actually attempt to approximately MOI match a set of clubs by "progressive swingweighting" - increasing the club swingweight by typically 1/2 swingweight point between clubs - for example, the 6 iron swingweight would be 1/2 point higher than the 5 iron swingweight.
Proponents of iron swingweight matching believe that you should determine the best iron swingweight - which produces the best performance - and keep that constant for your main irons - for example 5 iron through 9 iron. Most swingweight proponents I believe feel that the wedges should have a bit higher swingweights than the other irons.
Proponents of MOI matching believe that you identify the best iron MOI for the player and then build the full set of irons to that MOI. They also believe that if you have a set of MOI matched clubs, that you can ask a player to swing their 5 iron and 9 iron with their eyes closed and they will not be able to tell you which one they are swinging.
So why am I making a commitment to moving to applying MOI matching in all of my iron fittings? It is largely from feedback from some of the most influential clubfitters in the country and the world. I am aware of one fitter who has done more than 1,500 MOI iron fittings with excellent results, and of another who has done hundreds of fittings and had only 1 poor result. I also recently learned that MOI matched clubs are starting to make their way on the professional golf tours.
Having golf clubs that feel the same when you swing them to me is an edge that golfers should have available to them.
Tony
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
